Loading... Please wait...

Journal

How to Avoid Greenwashing: 'Plant-Derived' Ingredients Aren't So Great

Posted by Clara on

It's hard work being an educated consumer. There's so much slippery language and so many confusing terms that it's easy to get cynical and throw one's hands up in frustration. 

We're here to help. 

What Does 'Plant-Derived' Actually Mean?

'Plant-derived' sounds really impressive initially. Reading through a long list of ingredients on many 'natural' brands, it's easy to think that the 'plant-derived' ingredients are every bit as natural as 'plant-based' ingredients. But this isn't the case. It's might be easy to think of it like this: 'plant-derived' ingredients are like a xerox of a xerox of a xerox of a xerox. If you look really closely, you can still vaguely make-out the original, but it's nothing like the final product.

(Do you remember xeroxes?)

'Plant-derived' ingredients are often completely altered in a lab or through a number of chemical processes that leave little or nothing of the actual plant in a recognizable form. To say that cocamidopropyl hydroxysultaine is "made from coconut" is not really a lie. Long ago, it was coconut. It's just been chemically altered in the meantime to become a synthetic surfactant (cleanser) and a foam booster. To be clear though, in that process, it lost most of the properties that made it recognizable as 'coconut'. That this ingredient is still identified on labels as 'made from coconut' is intentionally misleading and attempts to confuse consumers into thinking that the product is still all-natural.  There are so many companies that present cocamidopropyl hydroxysultaine or sodium lauroyl methyl isethionate or even sodium laurel sulfate as quaint, natural ingredients that are somehow safer and less irritating because those ingredients came from coconuts. This simply isn't the case. 

We recognize that many consumers have been primed to expect that personal care products will foam and sting and dry the skin in order to feel as if the product is working. In reality, none of those qualities are necessary and usually point to the fact that there is likely some harm being done to the skin tissue. 

Look, we love a good lather with our organic soaps and body washes, but we achieve that by carefully formulating whole, organic plant oils to get the results we want and that our customers expect. We don't substitute cheapened and adulterated ingredients for what is truly plant-based and natural. 

What Can You Do?

We are not advocating that you avoid all products with ingredients that sound like a chemical. We just don't think that synthetics should be labeled as 'natural'. We simply think that companies should be truthful in their marketing and stop labeling their products and their ingredients as natural when they aren't. Read ingredient lists and don't be afraid to contact a company is something sounds fishy to you. We think 'natural' is important and the only way that term gets the respect it deserves is if 'natural' is taken seriously and properly labeled.

Find companies that you like, companies that list all of their ingredients truthfully and support them. These things matter.

View Comments


Back-To-School Giveaway!

It's Back-to-School Time and we're giving away a fantastic selection of our organic skin and body care products to a lucky winner. These lovely products are perfect for that high school or college kid on the go. They are also perfect for the person/s that raised the kid, if you want to keep all of [...]

Read More »


Hate Your Morning Shave? We’ve Got Something Different For You.

The sting of aftershave, the harsh chemical smell of shaving cream, a razor nick that aches for days…why is shaving so unpleasant? At Cultivar, we think a morning routine should be a soothing one that sets you up for a stress-free day. Our grooming products reflect that. Gone are the days of dry, itchy irritated skin. With our all-natural, [...]

Read More »


Vitamin B12 Deficiency Takes a Toll on Skin, Too

Has your skin been acting up lately? Have you been unusually tired? If so, there's a possibility that it could be a Vitamin B12 deficiency. Some studies* show that up to 40% of the US population is deficient in this single vitamin. I say this from experience because I recently realized that I had a Vitamin B12 [...]

Read More »


5 Reasons That You Need Our Organic Dry Shampoo

You already know that our dry shampoo is a quick fix for hair that needs freshening up. But if you’re nevertried our dry shampoo, you’ve probably never seen how healthy a simpledry shampoo can make your hair. Ours is different than anything else out there—here’s why.1. No residue. Most dry shampoos on the market are [...]

Read More »


To Wear or Not to Wear (Make-Up)

Every so often, someone famous will make a proclamation about no longer wearing make-up. The latest to make this announcement was Alicia Keys. My usual reaction when I hear about yet another woman making this pronouncement is to scoff and dismiss it as a publicity stunt (which, with the timing of Keys' most recent album, [...]

Read More »


Treating Summer Acne, Naturally

Summer is here. And as I look through the photos that I took in Vieques, I can't wait to feel the sun's warmth and smell the clean, fresh scent of the ocean again.  With all the fun, sun and humidity, many people will experience more breakouts than usual. There are some simple, easy-to-follow steps to [...]

Read More »


Fresh Summer Treats: Boozy Popsicles

One of my very favorite treats to make when it gets hot outside is boozy popsicles. Cocktails on a stick are endlessly versatile and are the perfect vehicle for fruit, herbs, and alcohol. The picture above is of Absinthe Mint Blackberry and Cucumber. Most any combination will work, just don't add more than 10% alcohol to [...]

Read More »


Cultivar: What's in a Name?

We were known by the brand skinnyskinny for more than 10 years. We were recognizable and we had great customer loyalty with that brand. So, why did we decide to change it? For a long time prior to making the decision to re-brand, I (as the owner/founder of skinnyskinny) had felt that the business had grown as [...]

Read More »


Cultivar Organic Soap-- Why Experience Matters

We love soap. It was the first product that we ever made more than 10 years ago (back when we were still known as skinnyskinny) and we are still in love with the combination of art and science that soap-making involves. Soap-making is not an easy thing to do. It requires mental focus, physical strength, [...]

Read More »